I agree entirely with the article quoted 風火燎原. In fact, I have serious doubts myself about how proficient some of these 11 so called 名師. I have already given an example of one of them who was confused himself as to whether North East should see water or South West should see water etc. There are other examples whom I have come across. It seems to me that the whole thing is publicity to bring them money and popularity more than anything else.

有冇看過這遍稿。看來有行家唔妥個公會揾人寫野：
http://fengshui68li.mysinablog.com/index.php?op=ViewArticle&articleId=1837890

「香港易學諮詢師公會」－ 玄學界反省的時候到了！Li | 20 July, 2009 | 一般

最近香港玄圈鬧得最哄哄的，相信必定是即將成立「香港易學諮詢師公會」了。而未入公會而又從事任何與術數有關的作業，據說將被視為違法！

據聞此公會將會於8月1日 舉行成立典禮，而當日會向十一位「香港知名易學從業人員」隆重頒授「國學文化諮詢師(易學)」的資格，並邀請全港傳媒出席見證。

巳獲公佈獲頒授有關認證的師傅，名單如下(按姓氏筆劃序)：王亭之、司徒法正、李丞責、何昭劻、林真、徐小明、 馬君程、黃卯、蘇志宗、蘇法根、觀龍。徐小明同時係會長。

不諱言時下易學巳經成為變左質嘅生財工具。混水摸魚、邪門左道舌哄無知大衆嘅騙棍俯拾即是。打着易學旗號推銷風水吉祥物擺响乜乜方位就五鬼運財，仲係年年新款要討你荷包。濫竽充數者有如過山之鯽！花招層出不窮，歪理誤盡蒼生！這次公會的成立，正係玄學界當頭棒喝的最佳反省時機！

唔怕得罪講老實話，嗰班出左名嘅玄學「大帥」有時都幾好笑，啲預測仲無寧兩可過電台財經演員。真正事後驗證準唔準嘅真係鳳毛麟角，反而事後孔明居多。就以近年轉戰台灣，仲响金融海嘯前預測台股升唔停而「聲名大噪」嘅「你都明」大帥，响2006「丙戌」年時嘅齋噏預測話係丙火通燥土「火毒之年」香江遭央。事實嗰年都幾風調雨順呀~~ 點知大帥馬後炮話嗰年夏天氣温升到37度中左佢「火毒之年」嘅預測。嘩！禁玄嘅嘢小記者真係唔曉。奇怪呢類攞住個流年干支就以片蓋全嘅所謂術數，居然從來沒有被質疑過。業界問題可見一班！

呢次首批「香港知名易學從業人員」入圍名單居然電視觀衆最受落嗰的「鬆人中」呀，「麥Ｃ奶」呀冇份，唔通佢地唔「知名」咩？嗰中反映普羅大眾其實對玄學真偽有幾分辨別能力呢？小記者認為良心教化公衆，等佢地認識五術係乜野，易學嘅功能同極限响邊度先至係正道！

事實擺在眼前，業界惡劣操守嚴峻不容我們再裝傻！餘下的只是要採取乜嘢方針對症下藥。術數界一直以來都是門派紛爭，良莠不齊仿如一盤散沙。家吓班玄學家又忽然「團結」起來，你話係咪令人思疑有「景轟」呢？假如存心以易學造福人羣，又何需多此一舉爭個無謂銜頭？！小記者擔心，今次呢班玄學家這麽齊心，講到尾咪又係名利$$$作怪！小記者對「香港易學諮詢師公會」的期望是有實在的業界整頓方案而不是泛泛空談。

小記者更不希望見到「香港易學諮詢師公會」冠冕堂皇手執業界牛耳；打響杜絕業內問題口號，最終變成徙具虛名、排擠非我宗派的謀私聚合。只怕公會成員的實質「日常會務」只是維護互相既得利益而終無建樹。做左幾十年人嘅都明白，世事往往「名氣」唔一定同「料子」「德性」掛勾，玄學界亦唔例外。如果呢批「香港知名易學從業人員」只係靠個「知名」埋堆而終日遊手好閒，小記者就真係冇眼睇。小記者更擔心，「香港易學諮詢師公會」演化成行業壟斷，立例杜絕入唔到圍嘅行家之後，餘下嘅少數既得利益者只顧瓜分玄學市場漁人得利。

人响徬徨無助嘅時候就揾風水帥算命帥求救，呢個時侯亦係最容易有機可乘。呢種情況業界從業者都心照不喧。雖然未致於姑息養奸，不過圈中人一直都係官官相畏，免得過都唔會挺身而出。小記者响圈打滾多年記億所及，只有兩年前「麥Ｃ奶」將羅庚南北指針掉轉左嗰鋪有人肯出嚟講吓嘢。冇計啦，「麥Ｃ奶」口臭得罪人多仲對啲新進後輩好似「帶子艇」佢地「豬多彈核」，個大籮柚先至比人踢瘀咋。不過呢次有人「伸張正義」响玄圈嚟講係例外架。呢種「各家自掃門前雪」嘅業界風氣會唔會因為成立個公會就得到改善呢？如果在位者心態依然，換湯唔換藥，「易學諮詢師公會」又點樣起到監管作用呢？

醫卜星相，唯獨是醫學有足夠條件作出科學量化同客觀分拆。玄學呢家嘢推算抽象响呢方面係望塵莫及。易學研究人士不乏高級知識份子，但礙於深奧的學問領域、宗流百花齊放不容易有共識。乜野人有資格攞呢個「易學資詢帥」銜頭根本就好難有客觀標準。係咪因為出左名或者寫過兩本著作就算有資格呢？這叫公平？又使唔使考過試睇吓巒頭功夫夠唔夠眼力? 修養精神同慧根又點樣去評審？究竟乜嘢人有足夠料子去操認證生殺權？歴史為鑑，權力必見腐敗，尤其易學缺乏客觀標準又點樣去確保呢啲權力既得者能夠公正無私？

小記者擔心，只不過借勢呢次小甜甜風水帥爭產案，有人以為整件乜野「易學資詢帥」銜頭就高人一等可以指指點點，設個門檻就可以獨攬天下。人有特殊身份好處就隨之而嚟，最終咪又係利益輸送。呢種權力轉移遊戲千古往來都係不變。歴史上掛着宗教正義為名，侵吞板圖為實嘅流血衝突死傷比任何愛滋瘟疫都要多。小記者實在唔忍心見到「易學資詢帥」呢個驚天「創舉」不外依樣葫蘆掛羊頭賣狗肉。

單係呢次公佈嘅認證名單巳經令人忍悛不禁。不諱言當中亦有表表專者，如 王亭之 先生即係小記者所敬仰。李承責帥承名門有貴氣小記者亦心服口服。新進年青玄學家之中，以呢位早兩年做左新郎哥嘅白淨靚仔响圈中評價算幾好架。

不過唔知點解徐小明會長有戲唔拍走嚟領導羣雄，唔通呢班「香港知名易學從業人員」响開幕禮表演龍虎舞獅助慶？原來只因任何其他成員當會長都會引起內哄，你話係咪有啲憨居？據聞徐小明湛緊重掌有綫娛樂台喎，唔知到時會唔會比班「易學資詢帥」上電親同肥媽 Maria Cordero又唱又跳宣傳吓呢？

「屍徒」帥傅唔使多介紹啦，澳門賭場要設翻個「慾擒先縱」風水局梗揾佢，輸到班賭客冇錢買船票返香港。「黃某」呢位宗帥啲花邊新聞都唔少架，佢鬧左好多年有行家將佢講義「鵲巢鳩佔」拾佢牙慧充有料。雖然話人之常情稍嫌胸襟不足。假如真心以易學厚德載物，又何需計較鄙吝視易學知識為私料？

咦，江湖傳聞仲話有人算錯左個黑道背景客人結果件事曝光播。作為「易學資詢帥」應唔應該收呢的污糟錢推算違法事情呢？下次咪制啦。寄望呢批認證名單唔係私相授受勉強撮合嘅結果！呢班新官上任為玄圈吹鷄嘅「易學資詢帥」，任重道遠好應該先行調節自己心志了！

權力越大，責任就越大！公會成員把關的是通往蒼生憂咎的命運鎖匙，天下間沒有比這更貴重了。務必憑良心做實事！

小記者口衰，不過係苦口婆心架！在此叮囑呢班「易學資詢帥」認真履行天職，不要借過銜頭謀取私利種惡業，更不要辜負上蒼對你地嘅期望呀！

(歡迎意見，爆料，投稿。聯絡小記者：fengshui68li@mysinamail.com)

I am not talking about Long Hair etc but one of the 11 so called 名師 who is going to receive the title of「國學文化諮詢師(易學)」

I have come across at least 3 of the so called 名師.

Let me tell you about them in turn.

One of them claimed himself to be a Professor of Feng Shui and is as good as any "State's Masters". He first taught and emphasized to his students the importance of "south west" should see water, "north east" should see mountain. Then, after a prolonged period, he suddenly told his students, he made a mistake, it should be "south west" should see mountain and "north east" should see water.

This is just one of the obvious contradictions in what he taught his students.

He also emphasized the importance of combining his clients' four pillars in reading feng shui but the truth is he knew very little about four pillars and relied on his students to do the reading for him before he worked out the feng shui arrangements for his clients.

I know where he got "North East" should see water etc from i.e. Master Chan Pui Sang and he tried to justify that by using Cheung Kong Center as an example. But when he first taught his students "North East" should see mountain etc, he was able to use other examples to justify his teachings.

These happened many years ago. I don't know what he is teaching his students now and whether his feng shui skills and knowledge have since improved so much that he has now elevated himself to be one of the 名師.

But to his poor old students, he certainly has confused them enough that they probably would hold a different view.

That's all for now. Will tell you more about the others that I konw...

放心啦！小弟師父上左大陸執業10幾年，以前幫過幾個省級領導人睇過風水，仲響中山大學任教過，佢話從來無收過關於呢件事既任何其他資料，況且中央亦都唔會咁蠢比一間香港既業餘學院話事(因為咁樣係違反一國兩制既界定)，呢單野根本就係老千野！

有關「國家」提名頒授「國學文化諮詢師(易學)」進一步消息讀者可以打開以下網誌閣讀:http://tongtianreporter.mysinablog.com/

i think 香港高等進修學院 owes those who took their examination an explanation and response to 通天記者's articles.

如果要界定術數師能否在中國大陸執業的話，應該由中華人民共和國、中央文化部或者宣傳部來決定授權，而唔係由一間區區既"香港高等進修學院"而決定喎！我相信呢單野都係呃錢既多！

呢個世界話之你，酋其是玄學界個個都是睇目前祗顧自己嘅利益。既然講到明背後有中央支持，仲會有邊個唔趨炎附勢？俾着你都會講飯氣唔講骨氣！如果唔係嘅話就跟唔上潮流，枉有一身功夫！唔使扯咁遠，特區政府可見一班...

所知上面名單內至少有三個係捉鬼大師，犯正中共之大忌。